The Upper East Side of Manhattan is renowned for its upscale boutiques, elegant brownstones, and—surprisingly—a delightful array of ice cream parlors. Whether you crave classic scoops, artisanal flavors, or unique dessert experiences, this neighborhood has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. This guide highlights 16 of the best ice cream shops the Upper East Side has to offer, ensuring your next icy treat is unforgettable.
Exploring the Sweet Delights: Top Ice Cream Shops on the Upper East Side
Finding the perfect ice cream shop can feel like searching for a hidden treasure. This list navigates you through the diverse offerings, from classic comfort to innovative creations. Each entry includes details to help you make the best choice for your next ice cream adventure.
Classic Creameries: A Taste of Tradition
These establishments offer the comforting familiarity of classic ice cream flavors, made with high-quality ingredients and served with a smile.
1. Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream: This isn't your average ice cream shop; Morgenstern's is an experience. They utilize unique ingredients and flavor combinations, pushing the boundaries of traditional ice cream. Their Black Sesame and Mascarpone with Fig Jam are particularly noteworthy. Expect a higher price point, reflecting the quality and artistry.
2. Ample Hills Creamery: With a focus on locally sourced ingredients, Ample Hills brings a farm-to-cone ethos to the Upper East Side. Their creative flavors rotate seasonally, offering a constantly evolving menu of delights. Look for their Ooey Gooey Butter Cake flavor—a true crowd-pleaser.
3. Grom: Hailing from Italy, Grom emphasizes using fresh, natural ingredients. Their gelato is exceptionally smooth and creamy, with a focus on classic Italian flavors. Try their Sicilian Pistachio or Dark Chocolate.
Unique & Artisanal Ice Cream Experiences
These shops stand out with innovative flavors, unique presentations, or a distinctive atmosphere.
4. Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream: Known for its creative and often unexpected flavor combinations, Van Leeuwen offers a diverse menu catering to adventurous palates. Their Honeycomb and Earl Grey Tea flavors are highly recommended.
5. Mikey Likes It Ice Cream: This shop is a local favorite for its inventive and occasionally whimsical flavors. You might find unusual options like Matcha Green Tea or Brown Butter Pecan.
6. La Maison du Chocolat: While primarily a chocolate shop, La Maison du Chocolat also offers exquisite ice cream, perfectly complementing their renowned chocolates. Expect a luxurious and refined experience.
Cafés & Dessert Destinations with Ice Cream
These locations offer ice cream as part of a broader menu, providing a more complete dessert experience.
7. Sarabeth's: This popular brunch spot also boasts a delightful ice cream selection, ideal for a post-meal treat.
8. The Smith: This lively restaurant and bar features a well-curated ice cream menu, perfect for ending a night out.
9. Cafe Boulud: This sophisticated French restaurant offers refined desserts, including artisanal ice creams, complementing their elegant atmosphere.
Beyond the Scoop: Ice Cream with a Twist
These establishments take ice cream to the next level with creative combinations and unique presentations.
10. Magnolia Bakery: Famous for their cupcakes, Magnolia Bakery also serves a classic ice cream sundae that is worth indulging in.
11. Eileen's Special Cheesecake: While renowned for their cheesecakes, Eileen's also offers ice cream that's a delicious complement to their signature desserts.
12. Levain Bakery: Known for their enormous, gooey cookies, Levain Bakery also offers ice cream, providing a perfect pairing for their famous treats.
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites
These under-the-radar spots offer a charming and personalized ice cream experience.
13. Sweet Melissa Patisserie: This charming French patisserie offers a lovely selection of ice cream alongside their exquisite pastries.
14. Maman: This popular bakery and café boasts a delightful ice cream selection, ideal for a casual afternoon treat.
15. Jack's Wife Freda: While primarily a restaurant, Jack's Wife Freda offers delicious ice cream that's perfect for ending a meal.
A Comparative Look: Ice Cream Styles
| Shop Name | Style | Specialty Flavors | Price Range | Ambiance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Morgenstern's | Artisanal, Experimental | Black Sesame, Mascarpone with Fig | $$ | Upscale, Modern |
| Ample Hills | Farm-to-Cone | Ooey Gooey Butter Cake | $ | Casual, Friendly |
| Grom | Italian Gelato | Sicilian Pistachio, Dark Chocolate | $ | Clean, Modern |
| Van Leeuwen | Artisanal, Creative | Honeycomb, Earl Grey Tea | $ | Casual, Trendy |
16. Your Neighborhood Grocery Store: Don't underestimate the quality of ice cream found in your local grocery stores! Many offer surprisingly high-quality options, especially in the Upper East Side.
Finding Your Perfect Upper East Side Ice Cream
This guide provides a comprehensive starting point for your Upper East Side ice cream adventure. Remember to check opening hours and consider making reservations, especially for the more popular establishments. Enjoy your delicious journey through the world of ice cream!
