Ithaca, NY, a vibrant college town nestled in the Finger Lakes region, boasts a surprisingly diverse and delicious culinary scene. And what better way to experience the local flavor than by indulging in some mouthwatering buffalo wings? This comprehensive guide dives deep into the top 16 spots in Ithaca serving up the best buffalo wings, covering everything from classic styles to innovative twists. Get ready to satisfy your cravings!
The Classics: Tried and True Buffalo Wing Joints
These establishments have earned their reputations through years of serving consistently excellent buffalo wings. They are the gold standard against which all others are measured.
1. The Nines: A Collegetown Staple
The Nines is a long-standing Ithaca institution, particularly popular with Cornell University students. Their wings are known for their perfectly crisp skin, juicy meat, and a range of sauces from mild to intensely spicy. They often have daily specials that make a visit even more appealing. Many consider their classic buffalo sauce the benchmark for Ithaca wings.
2. Hector's: A Local Favorite
Hector's is another Ithaca favorite, offering a classic wing experience. Their wings are generously sized, well-seasoned, and cooked to a perfect golden brown. They're known for their consistent quality and friendly service, making them a reliable choice for any wing craving.
3. Collegetown Bagels: Beyond the Bagels
While renowned for their bagels, Collegetown Bagels also serves up surprisingly delicious buffalo wings. They often offer wing specials, particularly during game days. The wings are a great complement to their other menu items, making it a convenient stop for a complete meal.
Beyond the Basics: Unique Takes on Buffalo Wings
These restaurants offer innovative approaches to the classic buffalo wing, experimenting with sauces, flavors, and preparation methods.
4. The Ithaca Beer Company: Wings and Brews
Pair your wings with a locally crafted beer at the Ithaca Beer Company. They offer a selection of wing sauces that complement their extensive beer menu. Their spicy mango habanero sauce is particularly popular.
5. Glenwood Cafe: A Hidden Gem
Glenwood Cafe is a bit off the beaten path but well worth the search. They often have daily wing specials and their unique sauce combinations are a testament to their culinary creativity.
6. State Street Eats: Gourmet Wings
State Street Eats elevates the buffalo wing experience with gourmet ingredients and creative sauces. They may use higher quality chicken or offer more sophisticated flavor profiles. Expect a more refined dining experience.
The Spicy Sensations: For Heat Seekers
These establishments cater to those with a high tolerance for spice, providing wings with intense fiery flavor.
7. Buffalo Wild Wings (Ithaca): A National Chain
While a national chain, Buffalo Wild Wings still provides a reliable and widely-accessible option for those craving intense heat. Their blazin' sauce is legendary among spice enthusiasts.
8. Level 26: Rooftop Views & Fiery Wings
If you’re looking for a bit of a view along with your heat, consider Level 26. They often feature wing specials with extra spicy options. The combination of amazing city views and fiery wings creates a truly memorable experience.
The Casual Crowd-Pleasers: Perfect for Groups
These restaurants are ideal for larger gatherings, offering ample seating and a relaxed atmosphere.
9. Lost Dog Cafe: A Lively Atmosphere
Lost Dog Cafe offers a lively atmosphere and a wide variety of menu options, making it a perfect spot for groups of friends. Their wings are consistently good, and their overall ambiance is fun and casual.
10. Rongovian Embassy: A Unique Experience
Rongovian Embassy offers a unique and eccentric experience, with their wings being just one part of their eclectic menu. Their wings are a solid choice for those seeking something a bit different.
The Unexpected Gems: Hidden Treasures
These locations might not be immediately known for their wings, but they offer surprisingly good options.
11. The Dutch Oven: A Surprise Wing Option
The Dutch Oven is primarily known for other items, but their wings are a delicious, well-kept secret among locals. Their classic buffalo wings offer a tasty alternative when you're looking for something different.
Beyond the Traditional Buffalo Sauce:
These restaurants offer wings with various flavors, moving beyond the classic buffalo sauce.
12. Epiphany: Creative Sauces
Epiphany is known for its sophisticated menu, including surprisingly excellent wings with a variety of creative and unique sauces. Expect quality ingredients and interesting flavor combinations.
13. Parsons: A Restaurant with a Side of Wings
Parsons offers a sophisticated dining experience, with their wings providing a satisfying addition to a more refined meal.
For the Wing Connoisseur:
These establishments stand out for their commitment to quality and unique approaches.
14. Dano's Heuriger: A Unique Approach
Dano's Heuriger offers a unique take on wings, often incorporating creative flavor profiles or preparation methods that set them apart. Expect a more elevated wing experience.
Quick Bites & Takeout:
These are convenient options for grabbing wings on the go.
15. Top Tomato: Convenient and Tasty
Top Tomato is a convenient spot for grabbing a quick bite, with their wings being a simple and tasty option.
A Final Note:
16. Your Own Home: The Ultimate Wing Experience
With a little effort and the right recipe, you can make amazing buffalo wings at home! Numerous online resources offer helpful guides and tips. Experiment with different spices and sauces to create your perfect wing.
This list provides a starting point for your buffalo wing adventure in Ithaca. The best choice will ultimately depend on your individual preferences, whether you prefer classic buffalo flavor or something more innovative, as well as the atmosphere you're seeking. So grab your friends, and embark on a delicious wing-eating tour of Ithaca!
