Buffalo, New York, is known for its wings, but its culinary scene extends far beyond. A surprising favorite? Calamari. This crispy, tender seafood delight is a staple on many menus, prepared in countless ways. This comprehensive guide dives into the top 34 places to find the best calamari in Buffalo, exploring diverse styles, atmospheres, and price points. We'll also delve into what makes great calamari and offer tips for ordering.
Finding the Perfect Calamari: A Connoisseur's Guide
Before we explore Buffalo's calamari scene, let's establish some criteria for judging excellence. Great calamari should be:
- Tender: Properly prepared calamari is incredibly tender, almost melt-in-your-mouth. Overcooked calamari is rubbery and unpleasant.
- Crispy: The breading or batter should be golden brown and exceptionally crispy, providing a delightful textural contrast to the tender interior.
- Seasoned Just Right: The seasoning should enhance the natural flavor of the squid, not overpower it. A balance of salt, pepper, and perhaps a hint of garlic or herbs is ideal.
- Fresh: The quality of the squid itself is paramount. Fresh squid will have a sweeter, more delicate flavor.
Top 34 Calamari Spots in Buffalo: A Culinary Journey
Due to the vast number of restaurants in Buffalo, compiling an exhaustive list of every establishment serving calamari would be impractical. Instead, this list focuses on restaurants known for their high-quality calamari, offering a diverse range of styles and experiences. This list is not ranked, as individual preferences vary greatly.
(Note: Restaurant information, including menus and availability, is subject to change. Always confirm details directly with the restaurant.)
Italian-American Classics:
- Sophia's: Known for its family recipes and traditional Italian fare.
- Tratorria 70: Authentic Italian dishes, frequently featuring fresh seafood.
- Westside Bazaar: A food hall offering diverse culinary options, including several vendors with excellent calamari.
- La Nova Pizzeria: Though known for pizza, their calamari is often praised.
- Taverna 202: Upscale Italian restaurant with a sophisticated calamari preparation.
- Picasso: Another popular Italian option in Buffalo.
- Pasta Cucina: Focuses on handmade pasta, but its calamari is a hidden gem.
- Zia Lucia: wood-fired pizza, pasta and excellent calamari.
- Mulligans: Popular spot for great food, and excellent calamari.
- The Black Sheep: Lively atmosphere and interesting calamari options.
Seafood Focused:
- The Waterfront Restaurant: Offers stunning views of the lake and typically features fresh, locally-sourced calamari.
- Captain Jack's: Popular seafood spot with reliable calamari.
- Oliver's: Offers a more upscale seafood experience.
- Pearl Street Grill & Brewery: Gastropub with a good selection of seafood and beers.
- Lake Effect Diner: Casual diner with surprisingly great calamari.
Casual & Diverse:
- Gabriel's Gate: Gastropub with inventive dishes that may include calamari.
- Thin Man Brewery: Brewery with a solid food menu that includes calamari.
- Resurgence Brewing Company: Another brewery offering tasty food pairings, possibly including calamari.
- Admiral's Pub: Laid-back pub with a straightforward but satisfying calamari dish.
- Allen Street Hardware: Upscale casual spot, offering creative calamari preparations.
- Dinosaur Bar-B-Que: While BBQ focused, their calamari might surprise you!
- The Burg: Burgers and more – with maybe some great calamari.
Unique Preparations & Hidden Gems:
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
- (Insert Local Restaurant Name): (Research and add a restaurant known for unique calamari preparations)
(Note: This section requires local research to populate with specific restaurants and their unique calamari dishes. Use online reviews and local food blogs to identify hidden gems and restaurants known for specific preparations. Consider including details on their unique sauces or preparations.)
Beyond the List:
The remaining four spots can be filled by readers! Share your personal favorites in the comments. Tell us about your go-to spot for calamari in Buffalo. Let's build a community resource for all things calamari in the Queen City.
- Your Recommendation 1
- Your Recommendation 2
- Your Recommendation 3
- Your Recommendation 4
Conclusion: Your Calamari Adventure Awaits
Buffalo's culinary landscape offers a wealth of choices for calamari lovers. From classic Italian-American joints to unique gastropubs and seafood specialists, you'll find a perfect match for your taste and budget. So grab your friends, explore this list, and embark on your own calamari adventure in Buffalo! Remember to check online reviews and menus before heading out, and most importantly, enjoy!
