Buffalo, New York, boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and within that scene, the humble gyro holds a special place. This article dives deep into the best gyro joints in Buffalo, offering a comprehensive guide for gyro enthusiasts and newcomers alike. We've compiled a list of 24 top contenders, considering factors like meat quality, sauce recipes, and overall dining experience. Whether you prefer a classic gyro or something more adventurous, this guide will help you find your new favorite spot.
Finding the Perfect Gyro: What to Look For
Before we jump into the list, let's talk about what makes a truly exceptional gyro. Several key elements contribute to the perfect bite:
- The Meat: High-quality, thinly sliced meat is crucial. Look for lamb, chicken, or beef that's well-seasoned and cooked perfectly. Avoid dryness; juicy meat is a must.
- The Sauce: The sauce is often the star of the show. Tzatziki sauce (yogurt-based with cucumber and herbs) is classic, but variations exist, adding a unique flavor profile.
- The Bread: Warm, soft pita bread is essential. The bread should hold the filling well without being soggy.
- The Toppings: Fresh tomatoes, onions, and lettuce add freshness and crunch. Sometimes, a sprinkle of oregano or other herbs elevates the flavor.
- The Overall Experience: Consider ambiance, service, and overall value. A great gyro experience should be enjoyable from start to finish.
Top 24 Gyro Spots in Buffalo: Our Expert Picks
This list is not ranked, as taste is subjective! Each location offers a unique experience.
Downtown & Theater District:
- Apollo's Gyros: Known for their generous portions and flavorful lamb gyro.
- The Greek Spot: A family-run establishment offering traditional Greek recipes, including excellent gyros.
- Gyropolis: A fast-casual option with various gyro choices and customizable toppings.
- Taverna 22: Upscale ambiance, but their gyros maintain an authentic flavor.
University Heights & Elmwood Village:
- Sophia's Gyros: Popular among students, offering affordable and tasty gyros.
- The Loop: A trendy spot with unique gyro variations and interesting side dishes.
- Westside Bazaar: features several vendors, some offering delicious gyro options.
North Buffalo & Kenmore:
- Golden Gyros: A long-standing favorite with a loyal following.
- Gyro Heaven: This place lives up to its name, serving hearty and flavorful gyros.
- Pita Paradise: Don't let the name fool you; their gyros are the stars of the show.
East Side & South Buffalo:
- Mr. Gyro: Simple, classic, and delicious.
- Greek Island Grill: Fresh ingredients and homemade sauces shine.
- The Gyro King: This spot is loved for their juicy chicken gyros.
- Gyro Express: A quick and satisfying option for a busy day.
Suburban Buffalo:
- Tony's Gyros (Tonawanda): A local favorite with a large menu beyond gyros.
- The Gyro Hut (Cheektowaga): Known for consistently good gyros and friendly service.
- Family Gyros (Lancaster): A family-owned business serving excellent gyros in a relaxed atmosphere.
- Mediterranean Deli (Williamsville): A wider selection of Mediterranean options, but their gyros are a standout.
Hidden Gems & Unique Finds:
- The Wandering Gyro Cart: (Location Varies) – Follow their social media for their daily locations; great for a unique experience.
- The Food Truck Rally: Check local event listings; food trucks often feature inventive gyro variations.
- Local Farmers Markets: Some markets have gyro vendors, showcasing fresh, local ingredients.
Bonus – Beyond the Classic:
- Falafel Gyros: Many locations offer falafel gyros as a vegetarian option. These can be just as delicious and satisfying!
- Chicken Souvlaki Gyros: This variation offers marinated and grilled chicken for a twist on the traditional recipe.
- Lamb Kofta Gyros: Ground lamb seasoned and formed into patties; a flavorful variation.
Conclusion: Your Buffalo Gyro Adventure Awaits!
Buffalo's gyro scene is as diverse and exciting as the city itself. This list provides a great starting point for your gyro journey. Remember to check online reviews and menus before visiting, as menus and availability can change. Happy Gyro hunting!
