Buffalo, New York, is known for more than just its wings. This vibrant city boasts a surprisingly diverse and delicious dessert scene. From classic comfort food to innovative creations, Buffalo's bakeries and restaurants offer a sweet escape for every palate. This guide explores 22 of the best desserts Buffalo has to offer, covering a range of styles and tastes. Prepare your sweet tooth!
Classic Comfort: Pies, Cakes & More
Best Apple Pies in Buffalo
1. Sophia's Restaurant: Sophia's isn't just known for its Italian-American cuisine; their apple pie is legendary. The flaky crust and perfectly spiced filling are a testament to classic baking techniques. They often sell out, so get there early!
2. Westside Bazaar: This vibrant food hall offers rotating options, but often features local bakers with outstanding apple pie variations. Look for seasonal fruit additions for a unique twist.
3. Your Favorite Local Bakery: Many smaller, independent bakeries throughout Buffalo offer exceptional apple pies. Don't be afraid to explore and discover your new favorite!
Decadent Cakes & Cupcakes
4. Lisa's Gluten Free: Proof that gluten-free doesn't mean flavor-free! Lisa's offers incredible cakes and cupcakes, catering to those with dietary restrictions without sacrificing taste.
5. The Pastry Room: This charming bakery is known for its exquisite decorated cakes. Perfect for special occasions or simply indulging in a sweet treat.
6. Enjoy! Chocolate: While not solely a dessert place, their chocolate creations, often incorporated into cakes and other sweets, are heavenly. Their rich, dark chocolate is a treat for serious chocolate lovers.
Beyond the Basics: Exploring Unique Buffalo Desserts
Ice Cream & Frozen Delights
7. Abbott's Frozen Custard: A Buffalo institution, Abbott's offers a classic custard experience. Choose from a wide array of flavors and toppings. Their seasonal flavors are particularly noteworthy.
8. Lake Effect Ice Cream: This local ice cream parlor focuses on locally sourced ingredients, resulting in inventive and flavorful ice cream.
9. Dairy Queen (various locations): While a chain, their Blizzards are a nostalgic favorite for many Buffalonians.
Candies & Confections
10. Williamsville Chocolate Company: This chocolatier produces handmade truffles and other confections, perfect for gifting or personal indulgence.
11. Sweetness: A charming candy store offering a vast selection of both classic and unique sweets. It's a great place to find a special gift or just browse and sample.
12. Sugar & Spice: Another local option for those seeking delicious, handcrafted candies and treats.
International Flavors
13. Taqueria Los Mayas: While primarily known for its Mexican cuisine, their churros are a must-try. Crispy, cinnamon-sugar dusted perfection.
14. Sophia's (again!): Their cannoli are a testament to classic Italian-American desserts. The creamy ricotta filling and delicate shell are a winning combination.
15. Any Polish Bakery: Buffalo's Polish heritage is rich, and many bakeries offer delicious Polish pastries, including paczki (jelly-filled doughnuts).
Hidden Gems & Unexpected Treats
16. Oliver's Restaurant: This restaurant offers unique dessert options that change seasonally, showcasing fresh, local ingredients.
17. The Black Sheep Restaurant: Known for its creative menu, The Black Sheep also boasts inventive and exciting dessert choices. Expect the unexpected.
Coffee Shop Delights
18. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que: While a barbecue joint, their peach cobbler is a legendary, sweet and smoky dessert.
19. Public Espresso: Many local coffee shops offer pastries and other baked goods. Check out your local favorites.
Seasonal Specials
20. Seasonal Farmer's Markets: Buffalo's farmer's markets often feature local bakers offering seasonal pies, cakes, and other treats. Check your local listings.
DIY Dessert Fun
21. Wegmans: This regional supermarket often has a surprising selection of unique and high-quality desserts.
22. Your Own Kitchen: Don't forget the possibility of making your own Buffalo-inspired dessert! Explore local recipes and create your own sweet masterpiece.
Conclusion: A Sweet End to Your Buffalo Adventure
Buffalo's dessert scene is a delightful mix of classic comfort and innovative creations. This list is just a starting point – explore, discover, and enjoy the many sweet treats this city has to offer. Happy eating!
