Ithaca, NY, boasts a vibrant downtown scene, and a big part of that vibrancy is its incredible food. Beyond the gorges and Cornell University, lies a haven for comfort food lovers. This guide dives into the top 19 spots offering delicious, satisfying meals that will warm your soul. We'll explore diverse options, from classic American fare to international comfort twists, ensuring there's something for everyone in your downtown Ithaca culinary adventure.
Classic American Comfort
1. The Nines: Elevated Comfort Food
The Nines offers a refined take on American comfort classics. Their menu changes seasonally, but you can always expect high-quality ingredients and creative twists on familiar dishes. Think perfectly cooked steaks, creamy mac and cheese elevated with gourmet cheeses, and seasonal vegetable sides that are anything but an afterthought. The atmosphere is upscale-casual, perfect for a special occasion or a celebratory dinner.
2. Ithaca Beer Company: Gastropub Goodness
No downtown Ithaca exploration is complete without a visit to the Ithaca Beer Company. Their gastropub menu pairs perfectly with their extensive craft beer selection. Expect hearty dishes like burgers, pizzas, and hearty sandwiches, ideal for sharing amongst friends while enjoying a flight of local brews.
3. Collegetown Bagels: Beyond the Bagel
While known for their incredible bagels, Collegetown Bagels also offers comforting breakfast and lunch fare. Think fluffy omelets, loaded breakfast sandwiches, and satisfying soups perfect for a chilly day. It's a casual, quick, and delicious option for any time of day.
International Comfort
4. Roux: Southern Charm
Roux brings the soul of Southern cuisine to downtown Ithaca. Their menu features classic dishes like fried chicken, shrimp and grits, and biscuits and gravy, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for a cozy meal.
5. ZaFalafel: Mediterranean Delights
Craving something a little different? ZaFalafel offers delicious and healthy Mediterranean comfort food. Their falafel, hummus, and shawarma are bursting with flavor, and their pita bread is perfectly soft and warm. It’s a lighter comfort food option, perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.
6. Little Venice: Italian Indulgence
Little Venice provides a taste of Italy in the heart of downtown Ithaca. Their pasta dishes are rich and creamy, their pizzas are perfectly crispy, and their tiramisu is a decadent must-try. It's a classic choice for a comforting Italian meal.
Sweet Treats & More
7. Treva: A Sweet Escape
Treva offers a delightful array of baked goods, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth. From cookies and brownies to decadent cakes and pies, Treva is a must-visit for any dessert lover. Their coffee is also excellent, making it the perfect spot for a coffee and pastry break.
8. Cinelli's: Ithaca Institution
Cinelli's has been a downtown Ithaca staple for years. Known for their delicious ice cream, it’s the perfect spot for a refreshing treat on a warm day or a comforting scoop on a cold one.
9. The Ithaca Farmers Market (Seasonal): Locally Sourced Comfort
During the warmer months, the Ithaca Farmers Market offers a plethora of local produce, baked goods, and prepared foods. It’s a great opportunity to experience the flavors of the region and create your own unique comfort meal from scratch.
Unique & Quirky Comfort
10. Hector's: A Local Favorite
Hector's is a downtown Ithaca institution, known for its casual atmosphere and delicious, classic American fare. It's a great spot for a no-frills, satisfying meal.
11. Moosewood Restaurant: Vegetarian Comfort
The Moosewood Restaurant offers creative and flavorful vegetarian comfort food. Their menu is constantly evolving, offering a unique culinary experience each visit. A great option for those seeking vegetarian or vegan comfort food.
12. Epiphany: Modern American Bites
Epiphany offers a unique take on modern American cuisine with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their menu changes regularly, but you can always expect delicious and comforting dishes that showcase the best of the region's produce.
Hidden Gems & More
13. Just a Taste: A Neighborhood Gem
Just a Taste might be small, but its comfort food is mighty. This hidden gem offers a variety of delicious sandwiches, soups, and salads. Perfect for a quick and easy lunch.
14. Burrito Shack: Casual Mexican Comfort
This casual spot offers massive and satisfying burritos, perfect for a quick and filling lunch or dinner. The ingredients are fresh and the portions are generous.
15. Govinda's Vegetarian Restaurant: Indian Comfort
Govinda's brings the warmth of Indian cuisine to downtown Ithaca. They offer a variety of flavorful vegetarian dishes, perfect for those seeking a comforting and exotic culinary experience.
Beyond Downtown (Worth the Short Trip!)
While technically outside of the immediate downtown area, these places are close enough to warrant inclusion:
16. Glenwood Bakery: Sweet Treats and More
Glenwood Bakery is known for its artisan bread, pastries, and sandwiches. Their bakery items can easily be classified as comfort food.
17. The Shack: Burgers and More
The Shack offers classic American comfort food with a focus on quality ingredients. Their burgers are juicy and flavorful, and their fries are perfectly crispy.
18. Khana Indian Restaurant: A Classic Comfort Choice
Khana offers a wide variety of flavorful Indian dishes perfect for a comforting and savory dinner.
19. Stella's: Creative comfort
Stella's offers a fun and unique menu with creative and comforting dishes.
This guide is just a starting point. Downtown Ithaca offers a rich and diverse culinary landscape, with countless options for comfort food. Explore, discover, and enjoy the many delicious offerings this vibrant city has to offer!
