Midtown Manhattan, a concrete jungle pulsating with energy, also boasts a surprisingly diverse culinary scene. And within that scene, a surprisingly competitive calamari market thrives. This isn't your average bar snack; we're talking about expertly fried, perfectly seasoned calamari, the kind that elevates a simple appetizer to a memorable experience. This guide explores the top 14 spots in Midtown NYC to indulge in this classic dish, offering a detailed look at what makes each location unique.
Finding the Perfect Calamari: What to Look For
Before diving into our top picks, let's discuss what constitutes truly great calamari. Several key factors contribute to a superior experience:
- Tenderness: The calamari should be tender, not tough or rubbery. This often depends on the freshness of the squid and the cooking method.
- Crispiness: A perfectly crisp breading is essential. It should be golden brown and shatteringly delicate, not soggy or oily.
- Seasoning: The seasoning should be balanced, enhancing the natural flavor of the squid without overpowering it. A simple salt and pepper blend can be surprisingly effective, while others may use more complex spice blends.
- Sauce: While some prefer their calamari plain, a delicious marinara or spicy aioli can significantly elevate the dish. The sauce should complement, not mask, the flavor of the calamari.
Top 14 Calamari Destinations in Midtown NYC
This list is curated based on online reviews, personal experiences, and a consideration of the factors mentioned above. It's arranged alphabetically, not by ranking, as taste is subjective!
1. Becco: Known for its upscale Italian cuisine, Becco's calamari often receives rave reviews for its light and crispy breading. They frequently use a simple seasoning that lets the quality of the squid shine through.
2. Carmine's: This popular Italian restaurant is famous for its generous portions, and their calamari is no exception. Expect a large, family-style serving perfect for sharing, with a classic marinara sauce.
3. The Clocktower: A sophisticated British restaurant, The Clocktower offers a more refined take on calamari. Their preparation may be slightly less traditional, possibly featuring unique seasonings or accompaniments.
4. Cipriani: This iconic Italian restaurant offers a luxurious setting and high-quality ingredients. Their calamari is likely to be prepared with meticulous attention to detail, reflecting the restaurant's overall elegance.
5. Del Frisco's Grille: An upscale steakhouse with a modern feel, Del Frisco's offers calamari as part of their broader appetizer selection. Expect a reliably good preparation, emphasizing crispiness and generous portions.
6. Fogo de Chão: A Brazilian steakhouse, Fogo de Chão's calamari might offer a unique twist, possibly incorporating Latin American flavors or spices.
7. The Lambs Club: This stylish restaurant provides a contemporary take on classic dishes. Their calamari preparation might feature unusual seasonings or a creative presentation.
8. Lilia: This popular Brooklyn restaurant with a Midtown location offers exquisite pasta and impeccable ingredients. Their calamari, while not the main focus, is likely to be fresh and flavorful.
9. Morso: An Italian spot in Midtown offers a cozy atmosphere and reliable Italian fare, featuring calamari as an often-praised starter.
10. O Ya: This upscale Japanese restaurant might offer a unique, sushi-inspired preparation of calamari, showcasing the freshness and quality of the ingredients. Expect a higher price point.
11. The Smith: A popular American brasserie known for its consistent quality and lively atmosphere. Their calamari is a reliable choice, often served with a classic marinara or aioli.
12. Urbanspace Vanderbilt: This food hall provides several vendors, some of which might offer calamari as part of their menu. Variety and price points are key here.
13. Vandal: This stylish restaurant and nightclub offers a more eclectic menu, possibly featuring unique or globally-inspired calamari dishes.
14. Virgil's Real BBQ: This BBQ joint might offer a surprisingly tasty calamari, possibly with a smoky or Southern-inspired twist.
Beyond the Calamari: Exploring Midtown's Culinary Scene
While this list focuses on calamari, Midtown offers a wealth of dining experiences beyond this classic appetizer. Consider exploring different cuisines and neighborhoods to discover your own hidden culinary gems.
Conclusion: Your Midtown Calamari Adventure Awaits!
Midtown NYC offers a surprising variety of locations to indulge in perfectly fried calamari. This list serves as a starting point for your own delicious culinary adventure. Remember to consider your preferences for seasoning, sauce, and overall dining experience when selecting your destination. Happy eating!
