Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is renowned for its vibrant Italian-American community and, naturally, its incredible pizza. This isn't just any pizza; we're talking about generations of tradition, secret recipes, and a level of deliciousness that's hard to find anywhere else. This guide dives deep into the top 13 pizza places in Bensonhurst, offering a taste of what makes each unique. We’ve considered factors like crust, sauce, toppings, overall taste, and of course, the neighborhood buzz. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey through the best pizzerias Bensonhurst has to offer!
A Delicious Deep Dive into Bensonhurst's Best Pizza
Finding the best pizza is subjective, but these 13 places consistently receive rave reviews and represent the diverse styles of pizza-making in Bensonhurst. Each pizzeria offers a unique experience, from classic New York-style slices to more modern interpretations. Let's explore!
Classic New York Style: The Legends
These pizzerias embody the quintessential New York-style pizza experience: thin crust, crispy edges, and a perfect balance of sauce and cheese.
-
L&B Spumoni Gardens: A Bensonhurst institution, L&B is famous for its Sicilian pizza. The thick, slightly sweet crust is baked to perfection, creating a delightful textural contrast with the rich tomato sauce and generous cheese. Their spumoni is also legendary. Keyword Variation: Bensonhurst pizza places
-
Lenny's Pizza: Known for its consistently excellent thin crust pizza, Lenny's offers a simple but supremely satisfying slice. They’ve perfected the balance of a crispy crust with a light, flavorful sauce. Keyword Variation: Best pizza Bensonhurst
-
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana: While technically a bit outside of Bensonhurst's core, it's close enough to warrant inclusion. Totonno's is a legendary, family-owned pizzeria that's been serving up classic Neapolitan-style pizzas since 1924. Their coal-fired oven gives the pizza a unique smoky flavor. Keyword Variation: Top rated pizza Bensonhurst
Beyond the Classics: Exploring Diverse Flavors
Bensonhurst's pizza scene isn't just about tradition; it's about innovation and exploration.
-
Grimaldi's Pizzeria (DUMBO): While not technically in Bensonhurst, this iconic Brooklyn pizzeria deserves a mention due to its proximity and phenomenal coal-fired pies. It offers a unique char and a slightly sweet taste. Keyword Variation: Bensonhurst pizza guide
-
Joe's Pizza: A popular choice for its generous slices and consistently good quality. They offer a wide variety of toppings to cater to different tastes. Keyword: Bensonhurst pizza
-
Denino's Pizzeria: Another coal-fired pizza option, Denino's offers a slightly thicker crust than Grimaldi's, and a rich, tangy sauce. Keyword: Pizza places in Bensonhurst
The Underdogs: Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
These pizzerias might not be as widely known, but they offer exceptional pizza and a true taste of Bensonhurst.
-
Pizza Moto: This modern spot offers creative pizza variations with high-quality ingredients. Their unique topping combinations are a welcome departure from the classics. Keyword Variation: Pizza in Bensonhurst NYC
-
Luigi's Pizza: A neighborhood favorite known for its friendly service and delicious, classic pies. It’s a perfect place to grab a quick and satisfying slice. Keyword Variation: Where to eat pizza in Bensonhurst
Sweet Endings: Beyond the Pie
Pizza isn't the only thing Bensonhurst excels at. These places offer additional delicious treats.
- L&B Spumoni Gardens (again!): We had to mention their spumoni again – a must-try after indulging in their Sicilian pizza.
The New Wave: Modern Pizza Concepts
- [Insert a new, trendy pizza place in Bensonhurst if one exists. If not, remove this section.] This section needs current information about newly opened pizza places in Bensonhurst to stay relevant.
Comparing Pizza Styles: A Quick Guide
| Pizzeria | Style | Crust | Sauce | Speciality |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| L&B Spumoni Gardens | Sicilian | Thick | Sweet | Sicilian Pizza, Spumoni |
| Lenny's Pizza | New York Thin Crust | Thin | Light | Classic Thin Crust Pizza |
| Totonno's | Neapolitan | Thin | San Marzano | Coal-fired oven, Neapolitan tradition |
| Grimaldi's | Coal-fired Neapolitan | Thin | Slightly sweet | Coal-fired oven, classic cheese and pepperoni |
Conclusion: Your Bensonhurst Pizza Adventure Awaits!
Bensonhurst boasts a truly diverse and delicious pizza landscape. Whether you're craving a classic New York slice or something more adventurous, this guide should help you find your perfect pizza paradise. So grab a slice (or two!), explore the neighborhood, and experience the vibrant culinary scene of Bensonhurst for yourself. Enjoy your Bensonhurst pizza journey! Remember to always check the latest reviews and hours of operation before your visit. Happy eating!
