Ithaca, NY boasts a vibrant food scene, and amidst the diverse culinary offerings, one delicious staple shines brightly: coleslaw. Whether you prefer a classic creamy version, a tangy vinegar-based slaw, or something uniquely Ithacan, this guide explores the top 13 places to find the perfect coleslaw to complement your meal or satisfy a craving. We'll delve into what makes each location special, highlighting unique aspects and customer favorites. Finding the best coleslaw is subjective, but this list provides a diverse range of options to help you discover your personal Ithaca coleslaw champion.
Classic Creamy Coleslaws:
1. The Ithaca Chop House: A Steakhouse Staple
The Ithaca Chop House is known for its upscale atmosphere and prime cuts of meat. However, their creamy coleslaw is a hidden gem, often praised for its perfectly balanced sweetness and tang. The creamy texture is rich and luxurious, complementing the savory dishes perfectly. Many reviewers mention its smooth texture and well-seasoned flavor.
2. The Nines: Elevated Comfort Food
The Nines offers elevated comfort food with a modern twist. Their coleslaw, while creamy, features a touch of unexpected zest – perhaps a hint of citrus or a unique spice blend. This isn't your grandma's coleslaw; it's a refined take on a classic. The precise recipe remains a secret, adding to its allure.
3. Collegetown Bagels: A Unexpected Delight
While known for their bagels, Collegetown Bagels offers a surprisingly delicious creamy coleslaw as a side to their sandwiches. This is a testament to the versatility of a good coleslaw recipe - it elevates even a simple sandwich. Its creamy base is balanced with a crisp, refreshing crunch.
Tangy Vinegar-Based Coleslaws:
4. Hector's BBQ: Southern Comfort
Hector's BBQ brings authentic Southern flavors to Ithaca. Their vinegar-based coleslaw is a testament to Southern culinary tradition, showcasing a bold, tangy flavor profile that perfectly complements their barbecue meats. It's typically lighter than creamy versions, offering a refreshing contrast to rich meats.
5. The Farmer's Market (Seasonal): Local and Fresh
Ithaca's vibrant Farmer's Market offers a rotating cast of vendors, some of whom specialize in coleslaw. During peak season, you'll find fresh, tangy coleslaws made with locally sourced cabbage and other ingredients. The variations and flavors are endless, showcasing the creativity of local farmers. Be sure to check the market schedule for availability.
6. Local Food Co-op: Community Choice
The Local Food Co-op frequently carries locally made coleslaws, often featuring seasonal ingredients and unique flavor profiles. This is a great option for supporting local businesses and trying out something new and exciting. The co-op also often offers tasting samples, allowing you to sample before committing.
Unique & Innovative Coleslaws:
7. Purple Sage Cafe: A Vegetarian Gem
Purple Sage Cafe offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan options, and their coleslaw is no exception. Expect a creative twist, perhaps with unusual spices, herbs, or a unique base, catering to health-conscious and adventurous eaters. Their coleslaw often showcases seasonal vegetables.
8. Glazed & Confused: Sweet & Savory Fusion
Glazed & Confused, a popular donut shop, might offer a unique take on coleslaw – perhaps a slaw with a sweet and savory twist, incorporating unexpected elements like maple syrup or candied pecans. This option is for those who like unique food combinations. Check their menu for current availability.
Coleslaw as a Part of a Larger Menu:
9. Govinda's Vegetarian Restaurant: Indian-Spiced Delight
Govinda's, a vegetarian Indian restaurant, might offer a coleslaw with an Indian flair. Imagine a slaw infused with curry powder, cilantro, or other Indian spices, creating a unique and flavorful experience. This showcases how coleslaw can adapt to various culinary traditions.
10. Luna Inspired Cuisine: Fusion Flavors
Luna Inspired Cuisine is known for its creative fusion dishes. Their coleslaw could incorporate elements from various culinary traditions, resulting in an unexpected and delicious combination. Expect a creative and innovative approach to the classic dish.
11. Rulloff's Restaurant: Classic Diner Charm
Rulloff's, a classic diner, likely offers a straightforward, yet satisfying, coleslaw. This is your classic diner experience, providing simple and dependable food.
Beyond the Usual:
12. Ithaca Beer Company: Unexpected Pairing
Though not a primary food venue, Ithaca Beer Company often offers food pairings during special events. Their coleslaw pairing might offer an innovative approach, combining the beer's flavor profile with a carefully crafted slaw.
13. Your Own Kitchen! : Homemade Happiness
Finally, don't underestimate the power of homemade coleslaw! With fresh ingredients and a little creativity, you can create your own perfect Ithaca coleslaw experience. Numerous online resources provide delicious recipes.
Note: This list is not exhaustive and restaurant menus change. Always confirm availability and current offerings directly with the establishment before visiting. Enjoy your coleslaw exploration in Ithaca!
