Little Italy, San Diego, is known for its vibrant atmosphere, charming streets, and delicious Italian cuisine. But beyond the pasta and pizza, a surprising culinary scene thrives: the chicken sandwich. This guide dives deep into the top 10 chicken sandwiches you absolutely must try in this unique San Diego neighborhood. We've considered factors like quality of ingredients, originality of the recipe, overall taste, and value for money to bring you this definitive ranking.
1. Filippi's Pizza Grotto: A Classic with a Twist
Filippi's, a Little Italy institution, isn't just known for its pizza. Their chicken sandwich, a surprisingly well-kept secret, features juicy, grilled chicken breast, crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, and a creamy pesto mayo on a toasted artisan roll. The pesto adds a delightful Italian flair that perfectly complements the savory chicken.
What makes it special: The unexpected Italian twist elevates a simple chicken sandwich to something truly memorable. The use of high-quality ingredients and perfectly toasted bread seals the deal.
2. Civico 1845: Elevated Italian-American Comfort Food
Civico 1845 offers a refined take on the chicken sandwich. Their version uses a buttermilk-brined, fried chicken breast, creating a wonderfully crispy exterior with incredibly tender meat inside. It’s served on a brioche bun with a tangy coleslaw and a spicy aioli.
What makes it special: The perfect balance of textures and flavors; crispy, tender, creamy, and spicy all at once. This isn't your average fried chicken sandwich.
3. Buon Appetito: Simple Perfection
Sometimes, the simplest things are the best. Buon Appetito's chicken sandwich is a testament to this philosophy. It features a perfectly seasoned and grilled chicken breast on a fresh roll with lettuce, tomato, and a light mayo. The focus is on the quality of the chicken itself, which is exceptionally juicy and flavorful.
What makes it special: The emphasis on quality ingredients shines through. It’s a classic chicken sandwich done right, without any unnecessary frills.
4. Monello: A Modern Take on a Classic
Monello, a trendy restaurant in Little Italy, offers a unique twist on the chicken sandwich. Their version features a crispy, double-fried chicken breast, with a spicy Calabrian chili aioli, pickled onions, and arugula on a toasted bun. The spiciness is balanced perfectly by the freshness of the arugula and the acidity of the pickled onions.
What makes it special: The creative use of Calabrian chili adds a distinct Italian kick, while the balance of flavors prevents it from being overly spicy.
5. The Nolen Rooftop: Panoramic Views and a Delicious Sandwich
While known for its stunning rooftop views, The Nolen also boasts a surprisingly good chicken sandwich. Their version is a gourmet fried chicken sandwich, featuring a juicy, flavorful chicken breast with a flavorful breading. It’s served on a potato roll with a unique slaw and a spicy mayo.
What makes it special: The combination of amazing views and a high-quality chicken sandwich makes this a unique dining experience.
6. Prepkitchen: The Health-Conscious Choice
For those looking for a healthier option, Prepkitchen's chicken sandwich is a great choice. They use grilled chicken breast, which is lean and packed with protein. It's served on a whole-wheat bun with fresh vegetables and a light vinaigrette.
What makes it special: A delicious and guilt-free option for those who are health-conscious but still crave a tasty chicken sandwich.
7. Puesto: A Taste of Mexico in Little Italy
Puesto, a popular Mexican restaurant, offers a unique take on the chicken sandwich. Their version features a flavorful, marinated chicken breast, which is grilled to perfection. It's served on a toasted brioche bun with chipotle mayo, avocado, and a vibrant slaw.
What makes it special: The Mexican influences add a refreshing twist to the classic chicken sandwich.
8. Ironside Fish & Oyster: A Seafood Restaurant's Surprise
You might not expect a great chicken sandwich at a seafood restaurant, but Ironside proves you wrong. Their version features a crispy fried chicken breast, served on a buttery brioche bun. It's simple, yet incredibly satisfying.
What makes it special: It's the unexpected find that will surprise and delight even the pickiest eaters.
9. Busalacchi's: Family Tradition Meets Modern Flavors
Busalacchi's, another Little Italy institution, offers a chicken sandwich that's both classic and innovative. They use a marinated chicken breast, grilled and topped with a flavorful pesto, roasted red peppers, and provolone cheese.
What makes it special: A great example of how Italian traditions can be creatively incorporated into a modern chicken sandwich.
10. Farmers Table: Farm-to-Table Goodness
Farmers Table prioritizes locally sourced ingredients, and this dedication shines through in their chicken sandwich. They use fresh, organic chicken breast, grilled and served with fresh vegetables and a homemade sauce.
What makes it special: The commitment to quality and locally sourced ingredients makes this sandwich a truly delicious and ethical choice.
Conclusion: Your Little Italy Chicken Sandwich Adventure Awaits!
Little Italy, San Diego, truly offers a diverse and delicious range of chicken sandwiches. Whether you prefer classic, spicy, gourmet, or health-conscious options, you're sure to find the perfect chicken sandwich to satisfy your cravings. So, grab your friends, explore Little Italy's culinary scene, and embark on a cluckin' good adventure! Remember to check restaurant websites for updated menus and hours. Happy eating!
