Shy's Original Steak House, located at 530 7th Avenue in New York City, is a classic steakhouse experience that has earned a reputation for its quality, atmosphere, and service. This in-depth review will explore the restaurant's menu, ambiance, and what past diners have said about their experiences, providing you with a comprehensive understanding before your visit. We'll delve into why Shy's maintains its popularity among both locals and tourists.
Shy's Original Steak House Menu: A Feast for the Senses
Shy's menu boasts a classic steakhouse selection, focusing on high-quality cuts of meat prepared to perfection. But it's not just steaks; the menu features a range of options to cater to diverse tastes.
Appetizers: Starting Strong
The appetizer section is a compelling prelude to the main course. Expect options such as:
- Shrimp Cocktail: Perfectly chilled and succulent shrimp served with a classic cocktail sauce.
- Oysters on the Half Shell: Fresh, briny oysters, a classic steakhouse starter.
- Escargots: A rich and flavorful preparation of snails, often served with garlic butter.
- Caesar Salad: A crisp and refreshing salad with creamy dressing and parmesan cheese.
This variety ensures that every diner, regardless of their preferences, can find something to enjoy. The appetizers at Shy's are known for their freshness and classic preparation, a hallmark of quality steakhouse dining.
Main Courses: The Star of the Show
Of course, the main attraction at Shy's is their selection of steaks. Expect cuts such as:
- Filet Mignon: The quintessential tender and lean cut.
- Ribeye: A flavorful and marbled cut with rich taste.
- New York Strip: A robust and flavorful cut known for its juicy texture.
- Porterhouse: A large and impressive cut, perfect for sharing.
Beyond the steaks, Shy's also offers other main courses, including:
- Lobster Tail: A decadent addition, showcasing fresh seafood.
- Chicken Dishes: Classic preparations for those seeking an alternative to beef.
- Chops: Lamb or pork chops, offering another protein option.
Shy's commitment to quality is evident in the sourcing of their ingredients. They prioritize sourcing the best cuts of meat available, resulting in an exceptional dining experience.
Sides & Desserts: Completing the Experience
The side dishes at Shy's are as carefully crafted as the main courses. Expect options like:
- Creamed Spinach: A rich and creamy classic.
- Mashed Potatoes: Creamy and buttery mashed potatoes.
- French Fries: Crispy and perfectly seasoned.
- Asparagus: Fresh and simply prepared.
The dessert menu features an array of classic options, providing a sweet end to the meal.
Drinks: Complementing the Meal
Shy's offers a comprehensive wine list, featuring a range of both domestic and international wines to pair perfectly with their steaks and other dishes. A variety of cocktails and other beverages are also available.
Shy's Original Steak House Reviews: What are People Saying?
Customer reviews offer invaluable insight into the Shy's dining experience. While specific reviews vary, several common themes emerge:
- High-quality food: Consistently praised for the quality and taste of their steaks and other dishes.
- Excellent service: Attentive and professional service is frequently mentioned.
- Classic atmosphere: The traditional steakhouse ambiance is appreciated by many.
- Price point: Shy's is a higher-end establishment, and pricing reflects this.
Online review platforms such as Yelp and Google Reviews provide a wealth of specific feedback. Reading these reviews can offer a more granular understanding of the Shy's experience.
Ambiance and Atmosphere
Shy's Original Steak House offers a classic, old-school New York City steakhouse experience. The décor is traditional, with dark wood paneling, comfortable booths, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. This creates an atmosphere conducive to both business dinners and celebratory meals. The lighting is subdued, contributing to a sophisticated and elegant feel.
Conclusion: Is Shy's Worth the Visit?
Shy's Original Steak House offers a refined and traditional steakhouse experience in the heart of New York City. The high-quality food, attentive service, and classic atmosphere combine to create a memorable dining occasion. While the price point is higher than some other restaurants, the quality and experience likely justify the cost for those seeking a special night out. Based on the overwhelmingly positive reviews, Shy's Original Steak House is a strong contender for your next upscale dining experience in NYC.
