Izzy's Smokehouse has quickly become a popular BBQ destination in New York City. This review dives deep into their menu, atmosphere, and overall dining experience to help you decide if it's worth a visit. We'll explore what makes Izzy's Smokehouse stand out (or not) in the competitive NYC culinary scene, examining both positive and negative aspects based on various online reviews and personal experiences. We'll also cover their menu in detail, highlighting their signature dishes and potential disappointments.
The Izzy's Smokehouse Menu: A Deep Dive
Izzy's Smokehouse menu boasts a wide array of smoked meats, sides, and beverages, catering to various tastes. Let's break down the key offerings:
Meats: The Stars of the Show
- Brisket: Often cited as a highlight, Izzy's brisket is typically described as tender, juicy, and flavorful. Many reviewers praise the smoky bark and melt-in-your-mouth texture. However, the quality can sometimes vary depending on the day and the specific cut.
- Pulled Pork: Another popular choice, the pulled pork is generally considered well-seasoned and moist, though some find it slightly less exceptional than the brisket. The level of smokiness can also fluctuate.
- Ribs: Both St. Louis-style and baby back ribs are available. Reviews on the ribs are more mixed, with some praising the tenderness while others noting a slightly dry texture at times. The quality appears to depend heavily on preparation and timing.
- Sausage: Izzy's Smokehouse offers various smoked sausages, often featuring unique flavor profiles. These are usually well-received, offering a good balance of spice and smoky flavor.
- Chicken: Smoked chicken is also on the menu, providing a lighter alternative to the richer meats. The quality and consistency of the chicken seem to be on par with other offerings, sometimes slightly drier than other items.
Sides: Complementing the Mains
The sides at Izzy's are an integral part of the dining experience. They offer classic BBQ accompaniments such as:
- Mac and Cheese: Creamy and cheesy, this is a popular choice, though some reviewers prefer a bit more sharpness in the cheese flavor.
- Collard Greens: Typically prepared with smoked meat, these greens offer a satisfyingly savory and slightly spicy counterpoint to the rich meats.
- Potato Salad: A creamy, classic potato salad, often lauded for its simplicity and balanced flavor.
- Cornbread: The cornbread is frequently described as moist and slightly sweet, a welcome addition to any BBQ meal.
Sauces & Condiments
Izzy's offers a variety of BBQ sauces, ranging from mild to spicy, allowing guests to customize their meal. The sauces are generally well-regarded, adding another layer of flavor to the smoked meats.
Izzy's Smokehouse Atmosphere and Service
The atmosphere at Izzy's Smokehouse is generally described as casual and lively. It often has a bustling feel, particularly during peak hours. The service is a mixed bag; some reviewers report friendly and efficient service, while others mention longer wait times or less attentive staff. This appears to be dependent on the time of day and staffing levels.
Overall Izzy's Smokehouse Review: Worth the Hype?
Izzy's Smokehouse delivers a solid BBQ experience, but it's not without its inconsistencies. The smoked meats, particularly the brisket, are generally excellent, offering a flavorful and tender culinary experience. However, the quality can be variable, and the service can sometimes lag.
Pros:
- Excellent Brisket: The brisket is a definite highlight, frequently praised for its tenderness and flavor.
- Good Variety: The menu offers a wide selection of smoked meats and sides.
- Lively Atmosphere: The restaurant typically has a fun and energetic vibe.
Cons:
- Inconsistent Quality: Some reviewers have reported inconsistencies in the quality of meats and service.
- Potential Long Wait Times: Expect potential waits, particularly during busy periods.
- Price Point: Dining at Izzy's Smokehouse can be relatively expensive compared to other BBQ joints.
Case Study: A recent Yelp review highlighted a positive experience with the brisket but noted slow service and slightly disappointing ribs. This showcases the inconsistency mentioned by several reviewers.
Conclusion:
Izzy's Smokehouse is a worthwhile visit for BBQ lovers in NYC, especially if you prioritize excellent brisket. However, be prepared for potential wait times and some variability in the quality of dishes and service. Manage expectations, and you'll likely have a satisfying experience. But don't expect perfection every time. Consider checking online reviews closer to your intended visit to gauge current customer feedback.
