Fette Sau, meaning "fat pig" in German, is more than just a name; it's a declaration. This Williamsburg, Brooklyn establishment has earned a reputation as a top-tier barbecue joint, consistently drawing praise and attracting long lines. But does the hype live up to the reality? This in-depth review explores Fette Sau's menu, ambiance, and overall experience, drawing on firsthand accounts and online reviews to give you a complete picture. We'll examine what makes this BBQ spot a New York City favorite and help you decide if it's worth the wait.
Fette Sau Menu: A BBQ Lover's Paradise
Fette Sau's menu is a testament to its dedication to quality barbecue. Forget fussy, over-complicated dishes. This is classic, smoky, meat-centric fare at its finest.
Must-Try Meats:
- Brisket: Consistently lauded as a standout, Fette Sau's brisket boasts incredible tenderness and a deep, rich smoky flavor. Many reviewers rave about the perfect bark-to-meat ratio, a hallmark of exceptional barbecue technique.
- Ribs: Both the pork ribs and beef ribs receive high praise. Expect fall-off-the-bone tenderness and a perfectly balanced smoky sweetness.
- Sausage: Their house-made sausage is a frequently mentioned favorite, often described as juicy and flavorful, perfectly complementing the other meats.
- Chicken: While less prominently featured than the other meats, the chicken is often cited as a reliable choice, well-seasoned and properly cooked.
Sides That Shine:
While the meats are the stars of the show, the sides at Fette Sau are no afterthought.
- Collard Greens: These are a must-try for many, cooked until tender but still maintaining a bit of bite.
- Mac and Cheese: Creamy, cheesy, and comforting – a perfect complement to the richness of the meats.
- Potato Salad: Though opinions vary slightly, the potato salad often earns positive mentions for its creamy texture and subtle seasoning.
- Cornbread: A slightly sweet and moist cornbread, often described as a perfect accompaniment to mop up the delicious BBQ sauces.
Note: The menu may change seasonally, so be sure to check their website for the most up-to-date offerings.
Ambiance and Atmosphere: Industrial Chic Meets BBQ Charm
Fette Sau's ambiance is as much a part of the experience as the food itself. The restaurant's industrial-chic design features exposed brick, wooden tables, and a generally rustic feel. It's a comfortable and lively space, perfect for a casual meal with friends or a more intimate dinner. The open kitchen allows you to witness the BBQ magic in action, adding to the overall experience. However, be prepared for a potentially noisy environment, especially on busy nights.
Fette Sau Reviews: What the Public Says
Online reviews paint a generally positive picture of Fette Sau. Sites like Yelp and Google Reviews are filled with comments praising the quality of the meats, the generous portions, and the overall atmosphere. However, the long wait times are a recurring theme. Many reviewers advise arriving early or being prepared to wait for a table, especially on weekends.
Positive Reviews Often Mention:
- Exceptional Quality Meats: The consistently high quality of the smoked meats is a major draw.
- Generous Portions: Most reviewers agree that the portions are more than ample.
- Friendly Service: While the wait may be long, the service is often cited as friendly and attentive.
- Great Atmosphere: The industrial-chic setting creates a lively and enjoyable dining experience.
Negative Reviews Often Mention:
- Long Wait Times: This is the most frequent complaint, with some reviewers reporting hour-long waits.
- Price Point: While the quality justifies the cost for many, some find the pricing to be on the higher side.
- Limited Menu: The focus on classic BBQ means the menu is not expansive.
Is Fette Sau Worth the Hype?
The answer, based on extensive reviews and general consensus, is a resounding yes, with caveats. If you're a serious BBQ aficionado willing to brave a potential wait, Fette Sau delivers an exceptional dining experience. The quality of the meat, the generous portions, and the overall atmosphere combine to create a memorable meal. However, if you're on a tight schedule or prefer a quieter, less crowded environment, you might want to explore other options.
Beyond the Plate: Factors to Consider
- Location: Fette Sau's Williamsburg location is easily accessible by subway.
- Reservations: While reservations are not always available, checking their website is advised.
- Pricing: Expect to pay a premium for the quality ingredients and the experience.
- Wait Times: Be prepared for a wait, especially during peak hours.
Ultimately, Fette Sau provides a quintessential New York City BBQ experience. While the long wait times might deter some, the exceptional quality of the food and the lively atmosphere make it a worthwhile destination for those who are willing to put in the effort. The Fette Sau experience is about more than just a meal; it's about enjoying high-quality barbecue in a vibrant, unique setting.
