Brooklyn Crab has quickly become a New York City seafood institution, famed for its waterfront location, lively atmosphere, and of course, its delicious seafood. But what do the reviews really say? This in-depth look at Brooklyn Crab reviews and their menu will help you decide if it's the right spot for your next meal. We'll examine everything from the freshest catches to the overall dining experience, ensuring you're fully informed before you book your table.
The Brooklyn Crab Menu: A Seafood Lover's Paradise
Brooklyn Crab's menu is a celebration of fresh, seasonal seafood. While it changes frequently based on availability, you can always expect a fantastic selection of options. The core of their menu revolves around crabs, naturally, but extends far beyond.
Crabs, Crabs, and More Crabs!
- Steamed Crabs: The star of the show. Reviews consistently praise the freshness and flavor of their steamed crabs. Many mention the generous portions and the perfect seasoning.
- BBQ Crabs: A smoky, sweet, and savory alternative to the classic steamed crab. Reviews suggest this is a great option for those who prefer a bolder flavor profile.
- Garlic Butter Crabs: Rich and decadent, the garlic butter crabs are a favorite amongst those who appreciate a flavorful sauce. Many reviews highlight the perfectly balanced garlic butter flavor.
Beyond the Crabs: Other Menu Highlights
Beyond the crab options, Brooklyn Crab offers a diverse menu featuring:
- Seafood Platters: A feast for the eyes (and the stomach!). Expect a variety of oysters, shrimp, clams, and more, often accompanied by sides like corn on the cob and potatoes. Reviews frequently highlight the abundance and freshness of the seafood in these platters.
- Lobster Rolls: A classic New England favorite executed perfectly. Reviews praise the generous chunks of lobster meat and the buttery, toasted roll.
- Fish Tacos: A lighter option, perfect for a casual meal. Reviews mention the fresh fish and flavorful toppings.
- Sides: Corn on the cob, seasoned fries, and coleslaw are popular choices to complement the main dishes.
Sample Menu Pricing (Subject to Change):
| Dish | Price Range |
|---|---|
| Steamed Crabs | $$ |
| BBQ Crabs | $$ |
| Garlic Butter Crabs | $$ |
| Seafood Platters | $$ - $$ |
| Lobster Rolls | $ - $$ |
| Fish Tacos | $ |
| Corn on the cob | $ |
| Fries | $ |
| Coleslaw | $ |
Note: $$ indicates a high price point, while $ indicates a lower price point.
What Brooklyn Crab Reviews Are Saying: A Roundup of Opinions
Online reviews for Brooklyn Crab are overwhelmingly positive. Many reviewers consistently praise the following:
- Freshness of Seafood: The quality of the seafood is repeatedly lauded. Reviewers often emphasize the taste and texture of the crab meat and other seafood items.
- Lively Atmosphere: The waterfront location and lively atmosphere create a fun and memorable dining experience. Many reviewers describe it as a perfect spot for a casual get-together with friends or family.
- Excellent Service: While occasional exceptions exist, most reviews highlight the friendly and attentive service. Many reviewers mention the helpfulness of the staff in suggesting dishes and drinks.
- Beautiful Location: The outdoor seating area, with its stunning views of the water, is a significant draw for many diners.
However, some negative reviews mention:
- Price: The prices can be considered high by some, particularly for larger groups.
- Wait Times: During peak hours, wait times can be significant. Reservations are highly recommended.
- Inconsistency: A few reviews cite inconsistent experiences regarding food quality or service.
Tips for Your Brooklyn Crab Experience
- Make a reservation: Especially during peak seasons and weekends. Walk-ins are possible, but you may face long waits.
- Go early or late: To avoid the longest wait times.
- Dress comfortably: The atmosphere is casual, so dress accordingly.
- Bring cash: While they may accept cards, it’s always a good idea to have some cash on hand for tips.
- Check the menu online: The menu can change based on the season and availability of seafood.
Conclusion: Is Brooklyn Crab Worth the Hype?
Based on the overwhelming number of positive reviews, Brooklyn Crab certainly lives up to the hype for many diners. The fresh seafood, lively atmosphere, and beautiful location combine to create a memorable dining experience. While the price point might be a deterrent for some, the quality of the food and the overall experience make it a worthwhile splurge for many seafood enthusiasts. Just remember to make a reservation!
