Blue Smoke is a renowned barbecue restaurant with locations in New York City. This in-depth review explores its menu, ambiance, service, and overall dining experience, drawing from various online reviews and personal experiences to provide a comprehensive picture for potential diners. We'll examine what makes Blue Smoke stand out (or fall short) compared to other BBQ establishments in the competitive NYC culinary landscape.
Menu Highlights and Must-Try Dishes
Blue Smoke's menu boasts a wide variety of classic barbecue dishes, incorporating both traditional Southern styles and creative twists. The menu changes seasonally, so it's always worth checking their website for the most up-to-date offerings.
Appetizers & Sides
-
Appetizers: Many reviewers praise the smoked wings and burnt ends, often described as exceptionally tender and flavorful. The BBQ shrimp also receives high marks, though some find them a bit pricey for the portion size. The mac and cheese is a consistent favorite, rich and creamy.
-
Sides: The sides are a strong point. The collard greens are frequently highlighted for their perfectly balanced seasoning and tenderness, avoiding the bitterness sometimes found in other restaurants. The cornbread is equally popular, moist and slightly sweet. The potato salad, however, receives mixed reviews; some find it too creamy, while others enjoy its classic simplicity.
Main Courses
The main courses are the heart of Blue Smoke's menu. The brisket is consistently ranked among the best in the city, known for its melt-in-your-mouth tenderness and deep smoky flavor. The ribs are another standout, often described as falling-off-the-bone tender with a perfect bark.
- Other options: They offer a selection of pulled pork, chicken, and sausages, all cooked with their signature smoky flavor. For those seeking something less traditional, there are also some creative options on the menu, like BBQ-glazed salmon.
Desserts
Blue Smoke's dessert menu is a pleasant surprise. The pecan pie receives rave reviews for its rich, nutty flavor and perfect texture. Other options typically include seasonal fruit cobblers and ice cream.
Atmosphere and Service
Blue Smoke’s atmosphere is upscale casual. The decor is sophisticated but inviting, creating a comfortable and lively environment. It's a popular spot, so reservations are highly recommended, particularly for dinner.
Service is generally considered efficient and friendly, though the level of attentiveness can vary depending on the time of day and the server. Many reviewers note that the staff is knowledgeable about the menu and happy to make recommendations.
Price Point and Value
Blue Smoke is not inexpensive. It's positioned as a higher-end barbecue restaurant, and the prices reflect that. While the food quality is generally high, some diners feel the portions could be larger for the price. This is a factor to consider when planning your visit.
Overall Review and Comparison to Competitors
Compared to other NYC BBQ restaurants, Blue Smoke occupies a unique niche. While some competitors offer a more rustic, down-home feel, Blue Smoke provides a more polished and upscale dining experience. Its strength lies in its consistent quality, sophisticated ambiance, and a menu that strikes a balance between tradition and innovation.
However, the higher prices may deter some budget-conscious diners. Competitors often offer larger portions or more affordable options. The best choice depends on your preferences and budget.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Does Blue Smoke offer takeout or delivery?
A: Yes, Blue Smoke offers both takeout and delivery options through their website and various delivery services.
Q: Are there vegetarian options at Blue Smoke?
A: While the focus is on barbecue, they typically offer a few vegetarian sides and possibly a vegetarian main course, depending on the season. It's best to check the current menu online.
Q: What are Blue Smoke's hours of operation?
A: Hours vary by location and day of the week. Check their website for the most up-to-date information.
Conclusion: Is Blue Smoke Worth It?
Blue Smoke provides a refined BBQ experience in NYC, offering consistently high-quality food in a stylish setting. While the prices are higher than many competitors, the taste and overall ambiance often justify the cost for many diners. However, consider your budget and preferences before booking, weighing the upscale ambiance and slightly smaller portions against the exceptional quality of the meat and sides. Blue Smoke is a great choice for a special occasion or a treat for yourself.
