Sheepshead Bay, a vibrant coastal neighborhood in Brooklyn, is renowned for its incredible seafood. And within that seafood paradise, one dish reigns supreme: calamari. This isn't just any calamari; we're talking about perfectly fried, tender, and flavorful rings and tentacles that define the Sheepshead Bay experience. This article dives deep into nine of the best spots to find this crispy delight, offering a detailed guide for your next seafood adventure.
Top 9 Calamari Havens in Sheepshead Bay
Finding the best calamari is a subjective journey, but these nine restaurants consistently receive high praise for their versions of this iconic dish. We'll explore what makes each unique, focusing on factors like frying techniques, breading, and overall taste.
1. L&B Spumoni Gardens: A Legendary Choice
L&B Spumoni Gardens isn't just known for its pizza. Their calamari is a beloved side dish, frequently mentioned in online reviews and among locals. What sets it apart? Many praise the light and crispy breading, which allows the tender calamari within to shine. The accompanying marinara sauce is often lauded as the perfect complement. Their calamari is a testament to the fact that even in a pizza-centric place, seafood can steal the show.
2. Gargiulo's Restaurant: Ocean Views & Exceptional Calamari
Gargiulo's offers a classic Sheepshead Bay experience – stunning waterfront views paired with exceptional seafood. Their calamari is no exception. Known for its generous portions and perfectly golden-brown fry, it's a popular appetizer. The restaurant's ambiance adds to the enjoyment, making it an ideal spot for a special occasion or a celebratory meal.
3. The Clam Bar: A Casual Calamari Classic
The Clam Bar embodies casual seaside dining. Their calamari is a crowd-pleaser, noted for its consistent quality and satisfying crunch. This is a place where you can enjoy fresh seafood without the fuss, making it perfect for a quick and delicious meal. The straightforward approach to the calamari highlights the quality of the ingredients themselves.
4. Rao's Clam Bar: A Family Tradition of Fine Calamari
Rao's Clam Bar is a Sheepshead Bay institution with a long-standing reputation for quality. Their calamari is prepared with care, boasting a delicate breading and perfectly cooked calamari. It’s a classic done right, showcasing the simple perfection that great ingredients can achieve. This is a place for a true taste of Sheepshead Bay tradition.
5. Lenny's Clam Bar: Fresh, Fast, and Flavorful Calamari
Lenny's is another popular clam bar known for its speedy service and fresh ingredients. Their calamari is a testament to that, offering a bright and fresh taste that’s not overpowered by heavy breading or oil. It’s a great option for those wanting a delicious and efficient seafood experience.
6. Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana: Another Pizza Place with Great Calamari
Similar to L&B, Totonno's, another pizza institution, offers delicious calamari as a complementary item. Their rendition is praised for its tenderness and generous portions. The contrast of the crispy calamari against the flavorful pizza makes for an interesting and satisfying meal.
7. Roll N Roaster: A Unique Calamari Twist
Roll N Roaster takes a different approach, often offering calamari as part of a larger meal. This allows for a unique culinary experience, combining the crispy calamari with other delicious elements. This might be a good option for those looking for more adventurous calamari options. Check their menu for current offerings.
8. John's of Bleecker Street: A Hidden Gem with Unexpectedly Great Calamari
While primarily known for their pizza, John's has quietly cultivated a reputation for excellent calamari amongst those in the know. Their version offers a balanced flavor profile with a perfectly executed crisp. It’s the kind of hidden gem that rewards those who dare to venture beyond the usual suspects.
9. Abruzzo's Restaurant: A Classic Italian Choice
Abruzzo's serves up classic Italian fare with a focus on fresh seafood. Their calamari is a consistent performer, often highlighted for its flavorful breading and satisfying texture. The restaurant’s atmosphere makes it perfect for a more formal or romantic dining experience.
What Makes Great Calamari?
The perfect calamari is a delicate balance of several factors:
- Freshness: The quality of the calamari itself is paramount. Fresh calamari cooks more evenly and has a superior taste.
- Breading: The breading should be light, crispy, and not overpowering. It should complement the calamari, not mask it.
- Frying Technique: Proper frying is crucial. Overcooked calamari is rubbery, while undercooked is slimy.
- Seasoning: A simple seasoning that enhances the natural flavor is ideal. Avoid anything too overpowering.
Finding Your Perfect Calamari
This list provides a strong starting point for your Sheepshead Bay calamari adventure. However, remember that taste is subjective. The best calamari is the one that you enjoy the most! Explore these restaurants, try their calamari, and discover your personal favorite in this delightful Brooklyn neighborhood. Happy eating!
