Finding the perfect lobster roll in Buffalo can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. But fear not, fellow crustacean enthusiasts! This comprehensive guide dives deep into the best spots in Buffalo to satisfy your lobster roll cravings. We've scoured the city, tasted the goods, and compiled this definitive list to help you navigate the delicious world of Buffalo lobster rolls. We'll explore different styles, pricing, and what makes each roll truly special. Get ready to indulge!
Types of Lobster Rolls to Expect in Buffalo
Before we dive into the top 18, let's understand the different types of lobster rolls you might encounter:
-
Maine-Style: This classic features chunks of lobster meat tossed in a simple mayonnaise-based dressing. It's all about letting the fresh lobster flavor shine.
-
Connecticut-Style: This version uses a warm, buttered roll and often includes a bit more seasoning or a touch of lemon.
-
Grilled Lobster Roll: The lobster meat is grilled, adding a smoky dimension to the already delicious seafood.
-
Lobster Roll with Add-ins: Some restaurants get creative, adding avocado, bacon, or other ingredients to enhance the lobster roll experience.
The Top 18 Lobster Roll Spots in Buffalo (Ranked!)
This list is based on a combination of factors: quality of lobster meat, taste of the roll, overall presentation, and customer reviews. Prices are approximate and can vary.
Top Tier (Exceptional Quality & Experience)
-
The Lobster Shack: (Price: $$) Known for its incredibly fresh, sustainably sourced lobster, this establishment offers a true taste of the Maine coast. Their Maine-style roll is legendary.
-
Seafood Haven: (Price: $$) Features both Maine and Connecticut-style rolls, using high-quality ingredients and skilled preparation. Expect a consistently excellent experience.
-
Pier 7: (Price: $$) Located on the waterfront, this restaurant boasts stunning views and equally stunning lobster rolls. Their grilled lobster roll is a standout.
Mid-Tier (Great Value & Flavor)
-
The Salty Siren: (Price: $) A popular spot offering a delicious and affordable lobster roll. Their unique take on the Connecticut style is a must-try.
-
Lake Effect Diner: (Price: $) A local favorite, they consistently impress with their fresh ingredients and generous portions. Their Maine style roll is a crowd-pleaser.
-
Canalside Eatery: (Price: $) A casual setting with a surprisingly high-quality lobster roll. A great option for a quick and satisfying meal.
-
The Blue Plate: (Price: $) Offers a creative lobster roll with interesting add-ins, while still maintaining the integrity of the lobster meat.
Budget-Friendly (Delicious without Breaking the Bank)
-
The Clam Shack: (Price: $) A no-frills spot serving up a tasty lobster roll without the hefty price tag. Perfect for a casual lunch.
-
Fish Tales: (Price: $) Great value for the quality of lobster you get. A perfect option for a quick bite.
-
Hook, Line & Sinker: (Price: $) Simple, straightforward, and delicious. They don't skimp on the lobster.
-
Captain's Catch: (Price: $) Another solid option for a budget-friendly lobster roll fix.
(The following are listed alphabetically, not ranked within this tier.)
- Anthony's Seafood Grill
- Big Catch Seafood Market
- Dockside Bar & Grill
- Island Breeze
- Lobster Landing
- Ocean's Bounty
- The Red Lobster (Chain Location)
Tips for Ordering the Perfect Lobster Roll
-
Ask about the source of the lobster: Knowing where the lobster comes from can help you assess its freshness and sustainability.
-
Consider the type of roll: Do you prefer a classic Maine or a warm Connecticut style?
-
Don't be afraid to try something new: Some restaurants offer unique variations on the classic lobster roll.
-
Check reviews: Before you go, take a look at online reviews to get a sense of what other customers have to say.
Conclusion: Your Lobster Roll Adventure Awaits!
Buffalo boasts an impressive array of lobster roll options, catering to every taste and budget. Whether you're a seasoned lobster connoisseur or a curious newbie, this guide will help you find the perfect lobster roll to satisfy your cravings. So grab a friend, head out, and enjoy the deliciousness! Happy eating!
