Coney Island, renowned for its boardwalk, amusement park, and beach, also boasts a vibrant culinary scene, especially when it comes to delis. These aren't your average sandwich shops; Coney Island delis offer a unique blend of classic New York deli fare with a seaside twist. This guide dives into the best 17 delis in Coney Island, highlighting their specialties and what makes them stand out. Whether you're craving a pastrami on rye, a juicy burger, or a classic knish, this list has something for every meat lover (and even some vegetarian options!).
The Top Contenders: Your Ultimate Coney Island Deli Guide
This list isn't ranked, as each deli offers a unique experience and caters to different tastes. Instead, we've categorized them to help you find your perfect match.
Classic Deli Experiences: The Stalwarts of Coney Island
-
Nathan's Famous: While known for its hot dogs, Nathan's also offers a full deli menu with all the classics. Their pastrami on rye is a must-try for a taste of history.
-
Gargiulo's: This iconic restaurant, a Coney Island landmark since 1908, is famous for its Italian-American cuisine but also offers incredible deli sandwiches. Expect generous portions and a family-friendly atmosphere. Their eggplant parmesan hero is particularly noteworthy.
-
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana: While primarily a pizza place, Totonno's also serves up some surprisingly delicious Italian-style deli sandwiches. The simple ingredients and fresh-baked bread are the star of the show here.
-
Lenny's Clam Bar: This establishment goes beyond its famous clams. They have a solid deli menu with fresh ingredients and generous portions, perfect for a casual meal after a day at the beach. Their lobster roll is highly recommended.
Hidden Gems: Discover the Underrated Deli Scene
-
Uncle Louie G's: A local favorite, Uncle Louie G’s offers delicious sandwiches, salads, and sides at affordable prices. They often have daily specials that are worth checking out.
-
Mike's Deli: This smaller, family-run deli offers a personal touch and consistently delicious sandwiches. Their customer service makes this a true neighborhood gem.
-
Beachside Bites: Located right on the boardwalk, Beachside Bites offers quick and easy deli options ideal for a casual snack or lunch while enjoying the sights and sounds of Coney Island.
Upscale Options: A Refined Deli Experience
- The Coney Island Brewery: While a brewery, The Coney Island Brewery also serves up a curated menu of high-quality deli sandwiches, perfectly paired with their craft beers. Their pastrami Reuben is a highlight.
Diverse Flavors: Beyond the Traditional Deli
-
Kim's Korean BBQ: While not strictly a deli, Kim's offers delicious Korean-style BBQ sandwiches that are a unique take on the genre.
-
Champs Diner: This retro diner offers classic deli-style sandwiches alongside their all-day breakfast and dinner menu. It’s a great option for a broader dining experience.
Quick Bites & Casual Choices: Grab-and-Go Deli Delights
-
Food Stands along the Boardwalk: Many food stands along the Coney Island boardwalk offer simple but satisfying deli-style sandwiches, perfect for a quick and easy meal on the go. Look for stands with fresh ingredients and positive reviews.
-
Boardwalk Pizza & Pasta: As the name suggests, this place focuses on pizza and pasta, but they also offer a selection of readily-available sandwiches. It’s a great option for a quick bite if you are close to the boardwalk.
Sweet Treats & Sides: Complementing Your Coney Island Deli Feast
-
Williamsburg Candy: While not a deli, Williamsburg Candy offers delicious treats to complement your deli meal. Consider a sweet treat after your savory sandwich!
-
Junior's Restaurant: While located a bit further from the main boardwalk, Junior’s is renowned for its cheesecake, a delicious end to any Coney Island deli adventure.
Unexpected Delights: Expanding Your Coney Island Culinary Horizons
-
Ruby's Bar & Grill: This casual bar offers some delicious deli-style appetizers and sandwiches, perfect for a relaxed evening.
-
Sideshow Bar & Grill: Similar to Ruby's, Sideshow offers casual dining with a good selection of sandwiches and sides. The atmosphere adds to the fun.
A Newcomer to Consider
- [Insert Name of New Deli Here, if applicable]: The Coney Island food scene is constantly evolving, so keep an eye out for new delis opening and adding to the culinary landscape.
Finding Your Perfect Coney Island Deli
The best Coney Island deli for you will depend on your preferences. Consider the following:
- Atmosphere: Do you prefer a classic diner, a casual boardwalk stand, or a more upscale setting?
- Menu: Are you looking for traditional deli fare or something more unique?
- Price: Delis in Coney Island range in price, so set a budget beforehand.
- Location: Consider proximity to other attractions you plan to visit.
This comprehensive guide provides a starting point for your Coney Island deli adventure. Happy eating!
