The Upper East Side is known for its upscale boutiques, elegant brownstones, and surprisingly, its incredible pancake scene. Forget the typical diner fare; this neighborhood boasts a diverse range of pancake options, from fluffy buttermilk stacks to inventive gourmet creations. This guide highlights the twelve best pancake spots in the UES, ensuring your next brunch is truly unforgettable. We'll delve into what makes each spot special, helping you choose the perfect pancake paradise for your taste and budget.
Fluffy Buttermilk Classics & Beyond: Top Pancake Spots on the UES
Finding the perfect pancake can feel like a quest, but fear not! We've done the hard work for you, sampling the best the Upper East Side has to offer. This isn't just about fluffy stacks; we're considering creativity, ingredient quality, atmosphere, and overall experience.
1. Sarabeth's: A UES Institution
Sarabeth's is a long-standing Upper East Side favorite, renowned for its consistently excellent food and charming atmosphere. Their pancakes are legendary – fluffy, light, and perfectly golden brown. They offer classic buttermilk pancakes, but don't miss their seasonal fruit variations, often featuring locally sourced ingredients.
- Why it's great: Consistent quality, charming atmosphere, classic options with seasonal twists.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: The seasonal fruit pancakes (check their menu for current offerings).
2. P.J. Clarke's: A Classic with a Twist
Known primarily for its upscale bar atmosphere, P.J. Clarke's also serves up surprisingly delicious pancakes. While not the focus of their menu, their pancakes are a hearty, satisfying option for those seeking a classic brunch experience in a sophisticated setting.
- Why it's great: Unexpectedly good pancakes in a stylish, historic setting.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Their classic buttermilk pancakes paired with their famous Bloody Mary.
3. The Smith: Trendy and Tasty
The Smith is a popular spot known for its lively atmosphere and delicious brunch menu. Their pancakes are thick, fluffy, and satisfying, offering a solid choice amidst a diverse menu. The presentation is always impeccable, enhancing the overall dining experience.
- Why it's great: Lively atmosphere, consistently good food, great for groups.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Their pancakes with seasonal fruit compote.
4. Russ & Daughters Cafe: A Unique Eastern European Twist
This cafe offers a unique take on the classic pancake, incorporating elements of Eastern European cuisine. While not strictly traditional, their creative pancake options are worth exploring for those seeking something different. Expect interesting flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients.
- Why it's great: Unique and creative pancake options, high-quality ingredients.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Check their menu for their unique pancake creations (they rotate seasonally).
5. Jack's Wife Freda: Mediterranean Flair
This stylish spot features a Mediterranean-inspired menu, and their pancakes reflect this influence. Expect creative flavor combinations and unique presentations. They're a great option for those seeking something beyond the traditional buttermilk stack.
- Why it's great: Unique Mediterranean-inspired flavors, stylish atmosphere.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Their ricotta pancakes (check their menu for current offerings).
6. Lexington Candy Shop: A Nostalgic Delight
Lexington Candy Shop offers a classic diner experience with a nostalgic charm. Their pancakes are simple yet satisfying, perfect for those craving a comforting, old-fashioned breakfast.
- Why it's great: Nostalgic atmosphere, classic diner feel, great value.
- Price range: $
- Must-try: Their classic buttermilk pancakes with a side of crispy bacon.
7. Balthazar: A French-Inspired Indulgence
Balthazar offers a luxurious French-inspired brunch experience. Their pancakes, while not the main attraction, are a decadent treat, made with high-quality ingredients and served with elegant presentation.
- Why it's great: Luxurious setting, high-quality ingredients, perfect for a special occasion.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Their pancakes with fresh berries and whipped cream.
8. Cafe Luxembourg: A Chic and Relaxing Spot
Cafe Luxembourg provides a chic and relaxed atmosphere perfect for a leisurely brunch. Their pancakes are a solid choice, offering a satisfying and delicious addition to their already extensive menu.
- Why it's great: Relaxed atmosphere, chic setting, great for a casual brunch.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Their classic buttermilk pancakes with maple syrup.
9. J.G. Melon: A UES Institution (with Pancakes!)
While primarily known for its burgers, J.G. Melon also serves up a surprisingly decent pancake. A great option if you're looking for something to complement other menu choices.
- Why it's great: Classic UES institution, good for a casual meal, convenient location.
- Price range: $
- Must-try: Their pancakes, a surprising addition to their primarily burger-centric menu.
10. Happy Bones: A Unique and Delicious Option
Happy Bones offers a unique and inventive brunch menu. While known for other items, their pancakes showcase creativity and high-quality ingredients, setting them apart from typical brunch fare.
- Why it's great: Unique and creative pancake options, high-quality ingredients.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Check their menu for their unique pancake creations (they change seasonally).
11. Ess-a-Bagel: Pancakes? Yes, They Have Them!
Ess-a-Bagel is a UES staple known for its legendary bagels. Surprisingly, they also offer a solid pancake option, ideal for those who can't decide between bagels and pancakes.
- Why it's great: Convenient location, solid pancake option alongside bagel favorites.
- Price range: $
- Must-try: Their classic pancakes – a pleasant surprise alongside their bagels.
12. Bluestone Lane: A Trendy Australian Option
Bluestone Lane offers a trendy Australian-inspired cafe experience. Their pancakes are a delicious option, offering a unique take on the classic, often featuring interesting toppings and flavors.
- Why it's great: Trendy atmosphere, Australian-inspired menu, interesting pancake variations.
- Price range: $$
- Must-try: Their ricotta hotcakes with seasonal fruit.
Choosing Your Perfect Upper East Side Pancake Adventure
This list showcases the diversity of pancake options on the Upper East Side. Consider your preferences – classic comfort food, innovative flavors, luxurious settings, or a casual atmosphere – when selecting your next pancake destination. Remember to check menus for seasonal variations and daily specials! Happy brunching!
