French toast. Just the words themselves conjure up images of warm, fluffy bread soaked in a rich custard, perfectly browned on the griddle, and maybe topped with some fresh berries and a drizzle of syrup. If you're in Buffalo and craving this breakfast (or brunch!) staple, you're in luck. The Queen City boasts a fantastic selection of restaurants serving up some truly exceptional French toast. This guide explores twelve of the best spots to indulge your sweet tooth.
Top-Tier French Toast Experiences in Buffalo
This list isn't just about finding a place serving French toast; it's about finding the best French toast experiences in Buffalo. We've considered factors like ingredient quality, preparation techniques, menu creativity, and overall dining experience.
1. Sophia's Restaurant: Classic Comfort Done Right
Sophia's is a Buffalo institution, known for its consistently delicious diner fare. Their French toast is a classic: thick-cut bread, perfectly custardy, and served golden-brown. It's simple, but executed flawlessly. They often offer seasonal fruit toppings which add a nice touch.
- Why it's great: No-frills, reliable, and consistently delicious. Perfect for a classic French toast craving.
- Special Feature: Often features daily specials with unique topping combinations.
2. Toutant: Upscale Southern Charm with a Twist
Toutant takes French toast to a whole new level. Expect elevated ingredients and creative presentations. Think brioche bread, house-made vanilla bean custard, and unique accompaniments like bourbon-maple syrup or seasonal fruit compote. It's a truly special treat.
- Why it's great: Elevated ingredients and sophisticated presentation. A perfect splurge-worthy brunch choice.
- Special Feature: Creative, seasonal variations on their French toast recipe.
3. Henry's Restaurant: A Local Favorite with Hearty Portions
Henry's is a beloved Buffalo spot, popular for its generous portions and home-style cooking. Their French toast is no exception. Expect thick slices, plenty of custard, and a satisfyingly crispy exterior. They don't skimp on the syrup either!
- Why it's great: Huge portions and a friendly atmosphere. Ideal for those with a hearty appetite.
- Special Feature: Excellent value for the money.
4. Westside Bazaar: A Culinary Melting Pot
The Westside Bazaar is a vibrant food hall showcasing diverse cuisines. While not exclusively known for French toast, several vendors offer unique versions, incorporating global flavors and ingredients. This is a great spot to discover unexpected and exciting interpretations of this classic dish.
- Why it's great: A unique opportunity to sample different cultural takes on French toast.
- Special Feature: Rotating vendors offer constantly evolving options.
5. Taqueria Los Mayas: A Surprising Delight
While primarily a Mexican restaurant, Taqueria Los Mayas might surprise you with their surprisingly delicious French toast. Their version is often lighter and less custardy, offering a nice contrast to more traditional offerings. This is an exciting choice for those looking for something slightly different.
- Why it's great: An unexpected gem with a lighter, unique style.
- Special Feature: A refreshing change of pace from traditional French toast.
6. Yalleys: A Cozy Cafe Experience
Yalleys is a charming café known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious breakfast menu. Their French toast is made with high-quality bread and a rich custard, resulting in a truly satisfying dish. They often pair it well with fresh seasonal fruits.
- Why it's great: Comfortable atmosphere and excellent coffee. A perfect spot for a relaxed brunch.
- Special Feature: Locally sourced ingredients, whenever possible.
7. The Black Sheep: A Gastropub with a Gourmet Twist
The Black Sheep offers a more elevated gastropub experience. Their French toast is often featured on their brunch menu, with creative variations using different breads and unique sauces.
- Why it's great: Upscale ambiance and creative French toast interpretations.
- Special Feature: Rotating brunch menu with frequent French toast specials.
8. Parkway Inn: A Classic Diner Gem
Parkway Inn is a classic Buffalo diner that's been serving up comfort food for years. Their French toast is a simple but satisfying option, perfect for a no-frills breakfast.
- Why it's great: A reliable choice for a classic diner experience.
- Special Feature: Fast service and generous portions.
9. Oliver's Restaurant: A Stylish Spot for Brunch
Oliver's Restaurant is a stylish spot known for its delicious brunch menu. Their French toast is often made with artisan bread and served with unique toppings.
- Why it's great: A trendy atmosphere and high-quality ingredients.
- Special Feature: Creative toppings and presentation.
10. Greiner's: A Neighborhood Favorite
Greiner's is a neighborhood favorite known for its friendly service and delicious food. Their French toast is a simple but satisfying option that's perfect for a casual breakfast or brunch.
- Why it's great: A cozy atmosphere and consistently good food.
- Special Feature: Friendly service and a welcoming environment.
11. The Tipsy Buffalo: Elevated Bar Food
The Tipsy Buffalo may surprise you with the quality of their French Toast, often featuring it on their brunch menu alongside craft cocktails.
- Why it's great: A fun atmosphere and creative cocktails to pair with your French toast.
- Special Feature: A great spot for a more social brunch experience.
12. Just Pasta: An Unexpected Treat
Just Pasta might seem like an unlikely place to find great French toast, but their version is often a delicious hidden gem.
- Why it's great: An unexpected surprise for French toast lovers.
- Special Feature: A unique menu offering an unexpected culinary journey.
Choosing Your Perfect French Toast Adventure in Buffalo
This list offers a diverse range of options, from classic diner fare to elevated gourmet experiences. Consider your budget, preferred atmosphere, and desired level of culinary creativity when making your choice. No matter where you go, you're guaranteed a delicious French toast experience in Buffalo! Enjoy!
